Why does the chimney leak more than the rest of the roof?
The chimney is a masonry block set into a roof that moves, and the metal around it has to move with both.
Brick and mortar expand and contract at a different rate from steel and aluminum, and each frost cycle works into every crack. The chimney also acts as a wall that catches wind-driven rain on the face it turns toward the storm, so the joint takes more water than a plain run of shingle does.
The joint is where three materials meet and two directions of movement collide, which is why it fails first. A repair that treats only the top edge, without the base or the cricket, buys one season, and then the stain comes back in the same place.
Is repointing the chimney part of the flashing repair?
Often, yes. Soft or missing mortar at the crown and shoulder lets water into the stack, and that has to be dealt with where it touches the metal.
Mortar that has eroded from the joints lets rain run into the brick, and it also loosens the grip of the counter flashing. Where the mortar is only lightly worn, repointing in a matching mix is enough. Where bricks are cracked or spalled, the crown or a section of the stack may need rebuilding first.
The masonry is usually agreed alongside the metal rather than as a separate project, because one depends on the other. A roofer who finds the crown in poor condition says so before the flashing is set, so the new metal is not fixed to a failing face.
Should the chimney cap be checked too?
Yes. A cap keeps water, leaves and animals out of the flue, and a missing or damaged one can send water down the inside of the stack.
A chimney without a cap lets rain fall straight down the flue, where it soaks the masonry and drips at the damper or the appliance. A cap that is cracked or bent is as much a source of water as an open flue, and it is inspected from the roof and, where the flue is reachable, from the top of the stack.
Any gap is noted in the written scope. The job is short, but it protects the masonry that the flashing relies on, and that is why the cap is checked on the same visit.
How far does a chimney repair reach across the roof?
The shingles on each side of the chimney are lifted and rewoven, so the repair touches several courses on every face of the stack.
Each course that runs under or over the flashing has to be relaid so water is shed in the right order, which means a repair on one side can disturb the shingles on the other. The roofer plans the lift so any change in color falls on a natural break rather than mid-slope.
Where the existing shingles are brittle they can crack when lifted, so the scope states how many courses are expected to be replaced. The homeowner knows the extent of the work before the crew is on the roof.
What if the chimney is no longer used?
An unused chimney still needs its joint sealed, because the stack and its flashing are still exposed to water and frost.
A chimney that has been capped or closed off above the roof is still a masonry block passing through the roof, and its flashing still takes the weather. A joint left unsealed lets water run down the old flue and into the house, sometimes long after the appliance has been removed.
Some owners take a chimney down entirely. That is a structural job with its own requirements, and the roof is closed over the opening in a separate sequence from the flashing work.