Why is the stain so far from the leak?
Water runs along the surface of boards and framing until it finds a gap, so the stain shows below the place where the water left the roof.
A joint that lets water in near the top of a slope may send it along a rafter for several feet before it drips. That is why the ceiling stain is not the place to repair. Water usually travels uphill from the stain, and the highest wet mark in the attic is a better guide than the drip itself.
Insulation slows the water and spreads it, so the drip can appear in a different room from the one where the water entered. A roofer checks the attic before the roof, because the attic often shows the path more clearly than the shingles do.
Is sealant a repair?
Sealant is a holding measure at best. It can close a small gap for a season, but it does not fix a joint that moves or was laid in the wrong order.
Caulk bonds poorly to wet or dirty metal and splits as the house flexes through temperature changes. Once a sealed joint fails, the water that sat behind the bead is trapped inside the assembly, where it rots the wood faster than the original leak did.
Flashing is a matter of lap and order: water must always run over a lower piece and never into a seam. Sealing a joint that was laid the wrong way round only hides the fault, and the repair that lasts changes the order.
How do I know which flashing has failed?
A roofer checks the metal, the shingles that overlap it and the fasteners, and looks for the place where water has run behind the metal.
Rust, pitting and gaps at a seam are the clear signs. Less obvious is a flashing that is still intact but was laid over the shingles instead of under them, which lets water in at its top edge. Lifting the courses above the flashing shows which way the metal was set.
Where the metal is old and thin, the whole run is replaced rather than one piece, because a worn sheet tends to fail at the next joint along. That judgment is made on the roof and explained before the work starts.
Can a leak come back after a repair?
It can, if the cause was not found or if the repair dealt with the surface rather than the joint.
A leak that returns is usually at a second joint that has been taking water as well, or at a point the first repair did not reach. The homeowner should treat the next long rain as the real test, and report any new stain at once rather than waiting for the ceiling to show it.
A repair is recorded with photographs, so a second leak can be compared against the first. The record also helps the next roofer, who will want to know what was laid and in what order.
What makes a leak job bigger?
The number of junctions, the age of the metal and how far water has reached into the structure set the size of the work, and each is written into the scope.
A single exposed flashing on a simple roof is a short job. Several junctions on a roof with dormers and a chimney, with wet sheathing or rot found behind the metal, is a longer one. Access also matters, since a steep slope or a tight lot changes how the work is reached and protected.
The scope is written after the trace is complete and before work begins. If rot is found, its extent is shown in the photographs and agreed before any further board is removed.