Why does a leak show up a long way from the hole?
Water entering a roof runs along whatever surface it meets before it finds a gap, so the stain marks where the water dripped through, not where it got in. The search starts above the stain and works upslope.
A pitched roof over a flat ceiling leaves a void full of framing, wiring and insulation. Water that comes through a cracked vent collar runs down the underside of a board, crosses a nail, soaks a strip of insulation and drops where that insulation stops. In older houses with knee walls and finished attic rooms, the same water can run inside a wall and show at a baseboard a floor below.
That is the usual reason a patched roof keeps staining. If the entry point was guessed rather than traced, the patch lands in the wrong place and nothing changes. A roofer who wants to see the ceiling and the attic, not only the shingles, is following the water rather than the most visible defect.
Repair or replace: where is the line?
Repair suits a local failure where the rest of the covering still has years left. Replacement becomes the better call when wear runs across the whole plane, when more than one layer is already on the deck, or when a third separate leak appears in one season.
A roofer is judging the condition of the entire plane, not only the damaged corner. Shingles that have lost their protective granules, that curl across most of the surface, or that crack when a tab is lifted have reached the end of their service life, whatever a single repair does to them.
Layers matter too. The City of Nashua's residential re-roof guidance allows a single existing shingle layer to be roofed over, which is one reason the count matters. Where the deck has been covered twice, a repair that looks sound may be sitting on boards nobody can see, and that is a fair reason to talk about replacement.
Will a repair match the shingles already on the roof?
Usually close enough that the repair is hard to see from the street, provided the old material is still pliable and the new work can be tied in at a natural break such as a ridge or a valley.
Shingle lines change with the years. A roof from one decade may use a different exposure, a different tab width or a heavier build than what is sold today, so one replacement course can stand out. A roofer checks the exposure and the condition of the old material before committing, and says so plainly if an exact match is not possible.
Where a color change cannot be avoided, the new work is usually carried to a ridge or a valley so the transition falls on a natural line rather than mid-slope. Brittle material sometimes will not lift without breaking, and then the honest answer is a larger section, not a forced fit.
How long does a repaired area last?
A well-detailed repair lasts about as long as the surrounding covering, but a repair on a tired roof only lasts until the next storm finds the next weak point.
The parts of a repair that count most are the underlayment and the flashing, because they sit beneath the visible shingles and carry most of the water load. Replacing them properly is what buys the years. Shingles laid over poor underlayment look fine and fail first at the edge where they were tied in.
The honest test is the next long, wind-driven rain, not a light shower. After a repair, keep an eye on the ceiling below the work through the next few storms and note any stain that appears, however small.
What makes one repair bigger than another?
Size, access, the age of the building and the condition of the decking decide how much work a repair turns out to be, and each one is explained in writing before work starts.
A short run of shingle on a single-story house is a different job from the same damage on a three-story building with a steep pitch and a rear stair. Access matters too: a roof reached only by a long ladder over a narrow lot, or past a porch that will not take a crew, adds set-up time and changes how the work is protected.
The age of the building matters because older decking and framing need checking, and the decking sometimes needs more than one panel. A roofer marks the scope on the roof and walks you through what is included and what is left out, so nothing turns up halfway through the day and nothing is added without your agreement.