What is the attic supposed to do in winter?
It should stay close to the temperature outdoors, so the roof deck stays cold and snow lying on it does not melt.
A cold attic is a quiet attic. Insulation on the ceiling floor keeps the living space's heat where it belongs, while the air above it holds the roof underside near outdoor temperature. Snow on the roof then stays frozen and does not turn into meltwater that flows down to the eave.
Trouble starts when the attic runs warm. Heat from bath fans, kitchen exhaust, plumbing stacks and recessed lights rises into the roof space, warms the deck and melts the snow above it. Venting removes the heat that gets through, but it cannot fully replace good air sealing.
Why does the soffit so often get blocked?
Insulation is blown or packed into the eave during an upgrade, and it covers the soffit vents and the air channel above the top plate.
Blown insulation is a common culprit because it spreads into any open bay, including the space nearest the eave. Once it covers the soffit, the intake is shut. A ridge vent above then has nothing to pull from, so the attic stays warm and the dam forms anyway.
Baffles are rigid channels set between the rafters at the eave, and they keep a clear path open above the insulation. They are simple to fit and are often missing from houses that have had a recent insulation upgrade. Checking the soffit from outside is the quickest way to see whether they are in place.
Can I add more vents to fix it?
Adding vents without fixing the intake and the air leaks often moves very little air, and it can make the roof worse.
A new vent cut into a roof with no soffit intake draws air from the living space through every gap available, including the leaks around the chimney and the attic hatch. That pulls warm, moist air into the roof space and can make the frost on the sheathing worse.
The sensible order is intake first, air sealing second and exhaust last, and each change is judged by what the attic does in the next cold week. A roofer who adds a vent before the intake is open is guessing rather than venting.
How do I know the attic is working?
A working attic is cold and dry in winter, shows little frost on the deck and has no visible moisture on the rafters.
On a clear, cold morning after a snowfall, the underside of the sheathing should show only a light frost or none. Heavy frost near the ridge means warm air is still reaching the roof. Dark staining on the rafters points to moisture getting into the attic, and that needs tracing back to its source.
The check can be repeated with a flashlight from the attic hatch, and it is worth doing each fall before the first heavy storm. The ice dam guide explains the wider pattern behind the dams.